| Franklin | Schulhofer | 2023 | Virginia Military Institute | 1 |
| Greyson | Brockman | 2023 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Hill | Plunkett | 2023 | Army West Point | 1 |
| Aidan | Wooley | 2023 | University of Richmond | 1 |
| James | Canipe | 2023 | Saint Joseph's University | 1 |
| Brayden | Williams | 2023 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Robbie | Walker | 2023 | Jacksonville University | 1 |
| Alex | Lobel | 2023 | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Garrett | Krsul | 2023 | Virginia Military Institute | 1 |
| Jack | Marlow | 2023 | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Myles | Quandt | 2023 | Towson University | 1 |
| Carson | Hall | 2023 | Loyola University Maryland | 1 |
| Anderson | Moore | 2023 | Georgetown University | 1 |
| Niko | Karetsos | 2023 | University of North Carolina | 1 |
| Donny | Scott | 2023 | Syracuse University | 1 |
| Daniel | Fazzari | 2022 | Queens University of Charlotte | 1 |
| Kyle | Kerrigan | 2022 | University of Vermont | 1 |
| Noah | Mclain | 2022 | Piedmont University | 3 |
| Riley | Hastings | 2022 | Lynchburg University | 3 |
| Ford | Stratton | 2022 | Rhodes College | 3 |
| Jim | Davis | 2022 | Rhodes College | 3 |
| Michael | Eisele | 2022 | Piedmont University | 3 |
| Caden | Canzano | 2022 | Centre College | 3 |
| Weston | Hammond | 2022 | Roanoke College | 3 |
| Carter | King | 2022 | Navy | 1 |
| Charlie | Lohman | 2022 | Colgate University | 1 |
| Bryce | Horton | 2022 | University of Utah | 1 |
| Garrett | Kelly | 2022 | Tufts University | 3 |
| Hayden | Downs | 2022 | Hofstra University | 1 |
| Julian | Robinson | 2022 | Hampton University | 1 |
| Sam | Blake | 2022 | Sacred Heart University | 1 |
| Max | Hull | 2022 | Drexel University | 1 |
| Nathan | Nicholas | 2022 | High Point University | 1 |
| Ethan | Landry | 2022 | Merrimack College | 1 |
| Charlie | Ciardullo | 2022 | University of Denver | 1 |
| Seth | Barnes | 2021 | Colgate University | 1 |
| TJ | Scott | 2021 | Limestone University | 2 |
| Tiernan | Pepple | 2021 | Limestone University | 2 |
| Shane | Kelly | 2021 | Belmont Abbey College | 2 |
| Zachary | Layne | 2021 | Belmont Abbey College | 2 |
| Brayden | O'Neill | 2021 | University of Alabama Huntsville | 2 |
| Taji | Flynn | 2021 | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Ari | Allen | 2021 | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Blake | Rowse | 2021 | Palm Beach Atlantic University | 2 |
| Max | Fritz | 2021 | University of Pennsylvania | 1 |
| Jack | Dunn | 2021 | UMass Amherst | 1 |
| Josh | Turner | 2021 | Palm Beach Atlantic University | 2 |
| Colin | Honroth | 2021 | Towson University | 1 |
| Rhett | Jones | 2021 | University of Tampa | 2 |
| Gabe | Lopez | 2021 | Belmont Abbey College | 2 |
| Jack | Manning | 2021 | Virginia Military Institute | 1 |
| Hunter | Coleman | 2021 | University of Alabama Huntsville | 2 |
| Pete | Fabrizio | 2021 | Belmont Abbey College | 2 |
| Mason | Morei | 2021 | Dartmouth College | 1 |
| Ethan | Storey | 2021 | Colby College | 3 |
| Eric | Fewell | 2021 | Piedmont University | 3 |
| Colin | Baez | 2021 | Jacksonville University | 1 |
| Eli | Hebert | 2021 | Rhodes College | 3 |
| Drew | Downes | 2021 | Rhodes College | 3 |
| Connor | Moore | 2021 | Lynchburg University | 3 |
| Steven | Crawford | 2021 | Amherst College | 3 |
| Finn | McCarthy | 2021 | Middlebury College | 3 |
| Dylan | Farley | 2021 | Loyola University Maryland | 1 |
| Corbin | Switzer | 2021 | University of Virginia | 1 |
| Luke | Rusterucci | 2021 | Virginia Military Institute | 1 |
| Evan | Voss | 2021 | Lenoir-Rhyne University | 2 |
| Carson | Reeder | 2021 | Sacred Heart University | 1 |
| Riley | Sullivan | 2021 | Lafayette College | 1 |
| Trey | Davis | 2021 | Anderson University | 2 |
| Cole | Monette | 2021 | Palm Beach Atlantic University | 2 |
| Luke | Catolico | 2021 | Sacred Heart University | 1 |
| Thomas | Lowman | 2021 | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Ethan | Cox | 2021 | University of Utah | 1 |
| Will | Mangold | 2021 | Jacksonville University | 1 |
| Fisher | Finley | 2021 | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| Sean | Byrne | 2021 | Army West Point | 1 |
| Andrew | Atchison | 2021 | University of Denver | 1 |
| Evan | Plunkett | 2021 | Army West Point | 1 |
| Braden | Erksa | 2021 | University of Maryland | 1 |
| James | Gurr | 2021 | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Eric | Malever | 2020 | University of Maryland | 1 |
| Cooper | Higgins | 2020 | Dartmouth College | 1 |
| Charlie | Higgins | 2020 | University of Denver | 1 |
| Gerald | Kane | 2020 | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Fulton | Buyman | 2020 | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| Jack | Neill | 2020 | Villanova University | 1 |
| Brian | Arp | 2020 | Berry College | 3 |
| Jamel | Segar | 2020 | Wheeling University | 2 |
| Maximus | Cummings | 2020 | Emmanuel College (GA) | 2 |
| Rhys | Day | 2020 | Providence College | 1 |
| Ridr | Knowlton | 2020 | Centre College | 3 |
| Jake | Schramm | 2020 | University of Alabama Huntsville | 2 |
| Alex | Gekas | 2020 | Army West Point | 1 |
| Will | Deskey | 2020 | Lehigh University | 1 |
| Shane | Tesler | 2020 | Cleveland State University | 1 |
| Zack | Catolico | 2020 | Emmanuel College (GA) | 2 |
| Ryan | Chambliss | 2020 | Swarthmore College | 3 |
| Parker | Cyr | 2020 | Bellarmine University | 1 |
| Matt | Schnetzka | 2020 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Nick | Floyd | 2020 | Saint Joseph's University | 1 |
| Will | Graves | 2020 | Haverford College | 3 |
| Max | Coopman | 2020 | Bellarmine University | 1 |
| Jack | Palmer | 2020 | Vassar College | 3 |
| Clyde | Bresnahan | 2020 | Denison University | 3 |
| Asher | Wagnon | 2020 | Furman University | 2 |
| Paul | Weathington | 2020 | Princeton University | 1 |
| Cameron | Herd | 2020 | Birmingham-Southern College | 3 |
| Garrett | Meuninck | 2020 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Ridge | Johnson | 2020 | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| Ryley | Cole | 2020 | Florida Southern College | 2 |
| Will | Stax | 2020 | Air Force Academy | 1 |
| Tommy | Marcoon | 2020 | Air Force Academy | 1 |
| Logan | Tucker | 2020 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Tate | Harran | 2020 | Bellarmine University | 1 |
| Tommy | Fialkowski | 2020 | Bellarmine University | 1 |
| MP | Thomas | 2020 | Navy | 1 |
| Andrew | Pederson | 2020 | Princeton University | 1 |
| Grant | Breyo | 2020 | UMass Amherst | 1 |
| Carter | Henry | 2020 | Yale University | 1 |
| Russell | Melendez | 2020 | Marquette University | 1 |
| Henry | Bonnie | 2020 | Dartmouth College | 1 |
| Ellison | Burt-Murray | 2020 | Marquette University | 1 |
| Hudson | Bohn | 2020 | Penn State University | 1 |
| Alex | Zappitello | 2020 | University of Maryland | 1 |
| Drew | Pritts | 2020 | Sacred Heart University | 1 |
| Justin | Sherrer | 2019 | University of Maryland | 1 |
| Chandler | Dula | 2019 | Williams College | 3 |
| Sam | Assaf | 2019 | Amherst College | 3 |
| Alex | Poma | 2019 | UMBC | 1 |
| Andrew | Konradt | 2019 | Trinity College | 3 |
| Max | Kane | 2019 | Air Force Academy | 1 |
| Zach | Musial | 2019 | Bryant University | 1 |
| Phillip | Malever | 2019 | Canisius College | 1 |
| Malachi | Smith | 2019 | Cleveland State University | 1 |
| Quinn | O'Donnell | 2019 | Denison University | 3 |
| Reid | Edelstein | 2019 | Denison University | 3 |
| Jason | Marx | 2019 | Reinhardt University | 2 |
| Cameron | Henry | 2019 | Duke University | 1 |
| Zack | Pacheco | 2019 | Georgetown University | 1 |
| Cade | MacLeod | 2019 | Georgetown University | 1 |
| Colton | Rudd | 2019 | Hofstra University | 1 |
| Carson | Kinnett | 2019 | Birmingham-South College | 3 |
| Taylor | Lewis | 2019 | Jacksonville University | 1 |
| Nick | Jessen | 2019 | Lafayette College | 1 |
| JP | Robinson | 2019 | Lafayette College | 1 |
| Ryan | Siracusa | 2019 | University of Maryland | 1 |
| Cole | Leggett | 2019 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Peter | Klueber | 2019 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Liam | Rosato | 2019 | Monmouth University | 1 |
| Maxim | Manyak | 2019 | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| Grant | Mitchell | 2019 | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Connor | Mitchell | 2019 | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Luke | McKernan | 2019 | Providence College | 1 |
| Brett | Meskill | 2019 | Sacred Heart University | 1 |
| Ryan | Overbay | 2019 | Saint Joseph's University | 1 |
| Charlie | Warren | 2019 | Sewanee: The University of the South | 3 |
| Graham | Blake | 2019 | Harvard University | 1 |
| Warren | Seeds | 2019 | Washington & Lee University | 3 |
| Rob | Hakes | 2019 | Lynchburg University | 3 |
| Malik | Gay | 2019 | Hartford University | 3 |
| Ian | McCauley | 2019 | Lafayette College | 1 |
| Tyler | Bradbury | 2019 | University of Utah | 1 |
| Grant | Jenson | 2019 | Rhodes College | 3 |
| Reid | Harrison | 2019 | Birmingham-Southern College | 3 |
| Shawn | Wilson | 2019 | LaGrange College | 3 |
| Cameron | Jones | 2019 | Limestone College | 2 |
| Johnnie | Banks | 2019 | Franklin & Marshall | 3 |
| Aaron | Miechiels | 2019 | Lenoir-Rhyne University | 2 |
| Drew | Childress | 2019 | University of Tampa | 2 |
| Will | Duffy | 2019 | Belmont Abbey College | 3 |
| Stanton | Smith | 2019 | Pace University | 2 |
| Dillon | Montineri | 2019 | Piedmont University | 3 |
| Justin | Wright | 2019 | University of Mount Union | 3 |
| Preston | Rhodes | 2019 | Bellarmine University | 1 |
| Will | Eudy | 2019 | North Greenville University | 2 |
| Franklin | Cecere | 2019 | Furman University | 2 |
| Stephen | Rinck | 2019 | Siena College | 1 |
| Derek | Saylor | 2019 | University of Montevallo | 2 |
| Josh | Rose | 2019 | University of Utah | 1 |
| Graham | Dixon | 2019 | Sewanee: The University of the South | 3 |
| Ryan | Blasberg | 2019 | Oberlin College | 3 |
| Jonny | Divirgilio | 2018 | Navy | 1 |
| Noah | Johnson | 2018 | Lenoir-Rhyne University | 2 |
| Bric | Nicholl | 2018 | Virginia Military Institute | 1 |
| Ryan | Hofstetter | 2018 | Sewanee: The University of the South | 3 |
| Reed | Weinberg | 2018 | Colorado College | 3 |
| Choice | Mostellar | 2018 | Saint Joseph's University | 1 |
| Nick | Mazza | 2018 | Huntingdon College | 3 |
| Ethan | Sack | 2018 | Lenoir-Rhyne University | 2 |
| John | Hennessey | 2018 | Hartford University | 3 |
| Garrett | LeClaire | 2018 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Kyle | Sendobry | 2018 | RIT | 3 |
| Ty | Tom | 2018 | Belmont Abbey College | 3 |
| Nicky | Solomon | 2018 | University of North Carolina | 1 |
| Quinn | Buczek | 2018 | University of Utah | 1 |
| Jack | Dennehy | 2018 | Navy | 1 |
| John | McCormack | 2018 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Sterlyn | Ardrey | 2018 | Hofstra University | 1 |
| Nathaniel | Raeder | 2018 | Navy | 1 |
| Nick | Ganem | 2018 | Furman University | 2 |
| Bailey | Williams | 2018 | Belmont Abbey College | 3 |
| Cole | Stevens | 2017 | University of Tampa | 2 |
| Adam | Corby | 2017 | Stevens Institute of Technology | 3 |
| Raines | Shamburger | 2017 | Duke University | 1 |
| Mick | Upchurch | 2017 | Princeton University | 1 |
| George | Baughan | 2017 | Princeton University | 1 |
| Eric | Cecere | 2017 | Siena College | 1 |
| Trent | Thomas | 2017 | Bellarmine University | 1 |
| Tyler | Bass | 2017 | Middlebury College | 3 |
| Niko | Gekas | 2017 | Georgetown University | 1 |
| Charles | Dumas | 2017 | Drexel University | 1 |
| Mack | Dickie | 2017 | Jacksonville University | 1 |
| Johnathan | Wood | 2017 | Sewanee: The University of the South | 3 |
| Luke | Sadd | 2017 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Mitchell | Ryan | 2017 | Sewanee: The University of the South | 3 |
| Jason | Kunath | 2017 | Monmouth College | 3 |
| Pierce | Johnson | 2017 | Hampton University | 1 |
| Sam | Asman | 2017 | Denison University | 3 |
| Andrew | Lempner | 2017 | Haverford College | 3 |
| Taylor | Dankenbring | 2017 | Providence College | 1 |
| Jason | Sullivan | 2017 | Cleveland State University | 1 |
| Connor | Callan | 2017 | Rhodes College | 3 |
| Nick | Rockefeller | 2017 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Jason | Floress | 2017 | Belmont Abbey College | 3 |
| Jimmy | Martelli | 2017 | Young Harris College | 2 |
| Connor | Owens | 2017 | Lynn University | 2 |
| Jake | Able | 2017 | North Greenville University | 2 |
| A'Santi | Blackshear | 2017 | Mount St. Mary's University | 1 |
| Michael | Brimer | 2017 | New Jersey Institute of Technology | 1 |
| Evan | Torris | 2017 | Lenoir-Rhyne University | 2 |
| Peyton | Bogard | 2017 | University of Maryland | 1 |
| Roman | Boothe | 2017 | Adelphi University | 2 |
| Ben | Clark | 2017 | Bucknell University | 1 |
| Ryan | Gallagher | 2017 | Rutgers University | 1 |
| Austin | Hudson | 2017 | Washington & Lee University | 3 |
| Eric | Overbay | 2017 | Villanova University | 1 |
| Jack | Patton | 2017 | Amherst College | 3 |
| Sage | Rieth | 2017 | Furman University | 2 |
| Bailey | Taylor | 2017 | Furman University | 2 |
| Ben | Wilkinson | 2017 | University of Richmond | 1 |
| Jonathan | Rose | 2017 | University of Utah | 1 |
| Nicholas | Rodman | 2016 | Washington & Lee University | 3 |
| Mike | Ryan | 2016 | University of Tampa | 2 |
| Chris | Price | 2016 | High Point University | 1 |
| Crosby | Matthews | 2016 | University of Delaware | 1 |
| Zach | Lynch | 2016 | Ohio Wesleyan University | 3 |
| Danny | Tesler | 2016 | Cleveland State University | 1 |
| Matt | Higgins | 2016 | Loyola University Maryland | 1 |
| Chris | Hadlow | 2016 | Piedmont University | 3 |
| Tyler | Kay | 2016 | Limestone University | 2 |
| Logan | Devereaux | 2016 | Loyola University Maryland | 1 |
| Will | Crane | 2016 | Sewanee: The University of the South | 3 |
| Anthony | Rosato | 2016 | Drexel University | 1 |
| Brady | Jenks | 2016 | Piedmont University | 3 |
| Logan | Bradford | 2016 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Drew | Van de Motter | 2016 | Florida Southern College | 3 |
| Tate | Gallagher | 2016 | University of Richmond | 1 |
| Griffin | Basile | 2016 | High Point University | 1 |
| Jeff | Durden | 2016 | Navy | 1 |
| Brad | Hadoval | 2016 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Matt | Chase | 2016 | Wesleyan University | 3 |
| Trevor | Stuart | 2016 | Furman University | 2 |
| Tyler | Borko | 2015 | Colorado College | 3 |
| Will | Pratt | 2015 | Sewanee: The University of the South | 3 |
| Josh | Dolan | 2015 | Washington & Lee University | 3 |
| Cole | Haverty | 2015 | University of North Carolina | 1 |
| William | Hudson | 2015 | University of Virginia | 1 |
| Hughes | Moffett | 2015 | Washington College | 3 |
| Cal | Pearce | 2015 | Sewanee: The University of the South | 3 |
| Langston | Rodgers | 2015 | Colorado Mesa University | 2 |
| Collins | Speed | 2015 | Washington & Lee University | 3 |
| Matt | Tanenblatt | 2015 | Dartmouth College | 1 |
| Charlie | Trense | 2015 | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| Trip | Wray | 2015 | Lafayette College | 1 |
| Nate | Solomon | 2015 | Syracuse University | 1 |
| Tyler | Wilks | 2015 | Providence College | 1 |
| McKay | Sheahan | 2015 | Fairfield University | 1 |
| Hank | Morgan | 2015 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Cal | Johnson | 2015 | Saint John's | 1 |
| Lucas | Wittenberg | 2015 | Georgetown University | 1 |
| Jake | Adams | 2015 | Jacksonville University | 1 |
| Mason | King | 2015 | Young Harris College | 3 |
| Garrett | Blake | 2015 | Young Harris College | 3 |
| Zach | Stephenson | 2015 | Belmont Abbey College | 3 |
| Preston | Tippett | 2015 | Air Force Academy | 1 |
| Andrew | Thomas | 2015 | Lynchburg University | 3 |
| Parker | Stevens | 2015 | Salisbury University | 3 |
| CJ | Hamilton | 2015 | Young Harris College | 3 |
| Bruce | Silk | 2015 | Young Harris College | 3 |
| Will | Curry | 2015 | Colorado Mesa University | 2 |
| Chad | Toliver | 2015 | Rutgers University | 1 |
| Colin | Fitzpatrick | 2015 | Young Harris College | 3 |
| Adam | Roberts | 2015 | Coker University | 2 |
| Janosch | Spohner | 2015 | Berry College | 3 |
| Sam | Schusted | 2015 | Rollins College | 2 |
| Drew | Lewandowski | 2015 | Reinhardt University | 2 |
| Colin | Wilcox | 2015 | University of Alabama Huntsville | 2 |
| Braiden | Davis | 2015 | University of Vermont | 1 |
| Thomas | Nofi | 2014 | Virginia Military Institute | 1 |
| Jake | Sadd | 2014 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Connor | McMeen | 2014 | Air Force Academy | 1 |
| Aswan | Bland | 2014 | Guilford College | 3 |
| Cole | Woodyard | 2014 | Guilford College | 3 |
| Parker | Styles | 2014 | Guilford College | 3 |
| Marco | Amalfitano | 2014 | Mercer University | 1 |
| Rob | Woolfork | 2014 | Virginia Military Institute | 1 |
| Hunter | Sanna | 2014 | Siena College | 1 |
| Nick | Zackucia | 2014 | UMass Amherst | 1 |
| Ben | Corrigan | 2014 | Lenoir-Rhyne University | 2 |
| Matt | McCarthy | 2014 | LIU Post | 2 |
| Michael | Holder | 2014 | Young Harris College | 3 |
| Patrick | Girard | 2014 | Haverford College | 3 |
| Alex | Schlosser | 2014 | Adelphi University | 2 |
| John | Stastny | 2014 | United State Coast Guard Academy | 3 |
| Jack | Cioffi | 2014 | Savannah College of Art and Design | 2 |
| Aaron | Ward | 2013 | Methodist University | 3 |
| Andrew | Eidenshink | 2013 | Fairfield University | 1 |
| Cash | Carlson | 2013 | Salisbury University | 3 |
| EJ | Thurmond | 2013 | Jacksonville University | 1 |
| Joe | Delia | 2013 | Greensboro College | 3 |
| Josh | Porter | 2013 | University of Tampa | 2 |
